Claude Opus 5.5 vs GPT-6 Astra vs Grok 4.7: Which frontier model should you actually pay for?
· 10 min read

Claude Opus 5.5 vs GPT-6 Astra vs Grok 4.7: Which frontier model should you actually pay for?

A beginner-friendly guide to Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6 Astra, and Grok 4.7 that compares what finished tasks actually cost, not just per-token price and why.

The beginner mistake is comparing the sticker price of a million tokens when the bill that matters is what a finished task actually costs. This comparison is based on official documentation, pricing pages, and published benchmarks — we did not run the models hands-on. So before you look at any price tag, start with the number that rarely appears in marketing: how many output tokens a model burns to finish one real task.

The trap: per-token price is not your bill

Per-token pricing tells you the rate, not the total. Grok 4.7 looks cheapest at $2 input and $6 output per million tokens, but a model that spends more tokens on a task can cost more overall. GPT-6 Astra prices higher per token yet finishes a measured Intelligence Index task for $3.26 at max effort — the lowest of the three.

A per-token price is like a taxi’s per-mile rate: it only becomes a bill when you know the distance. Artificial Analysis measures both the rate and the distance. GPT-6 Astra uses about 27K output tokens per Intelligence Index task at max effort and costs $3.26; at low effort the same task costs $0.82 (Artificial Analysis). Claude Opus 5.5 uses about 119K output tokens per task, and Claude Fable 5.1 uses about 78K (Artificial Analysis). Those differences decide your monthly invoice more than the headline price. If you compare only per-token prices, you will pick the wrong model for your workload. For a wider view of the field, see our AI model comparison hub.

Claude Opus 5.5: top score, longest thinking

Claude Opus 5.5 is Anthropic’s highest-scoring model: 58 on Artificial Analysis’s Intelligence Index, which the evaluator calls the highest score it has measured. It offers a 1M-token context window, 128K max output, and always-on adaptive thinking. At $4/$20 per million tokens it is not the cheap option, and it uses roughly 119K output tokens per task.

Anthropic released Opus 5.5 on 2026-09-22, and at $4 per million input tokens and $20 per million output tokens it is 20% cheaper per token than Opus 5 (Anthropic). Cache reads cost $0.20 per million tokens, a 95% discount, and the Batch API takes 50% off (Anthropic platform). Fast mode runs at $8/$40 with up to 2.5x speed. The 1M-token context window and 128K max output make it suitable for long documents, and the knowledge cutoff is June 2026. Adaptive thinking is always on and cannot be disabled, and Anthropic says output is 30%+ faster than Opus 5.

On independent tests it scores 1,822 Elo on AA-Briefcase, 1,846 Elo on GDPval-AA, 59.6% on Terminal-Bench 4.0, 61.4% on HLE, and 66.9% on SciCode (Artificial Analysis). The trade-off is token appetite: about 119K output tokens per task at max, versus about 78K for Claude Fable 5.1 and about 27K for GPT-6 Astra. Cost per task is level with Opus 5 despite 1.6x the output tokens. If you want a deeper Claude read, see our Claude Fable 5 review.

GPT-6 Astra: cheapest per finished task

GPT-6 Astra is the cheapest of the three per finished task. Despite listing at $10 input and $50 output per million tokens, Artificial Analysis measures $3.26 per Intelligence Index task at max effort and $0.82 at low, because it uses only about 27K output tokens per task. It also scores 62 on the Coding Agent Index in Codex.

OpenAI released GPT-6 Astra on 2026-09-03. Its API prices are $10 per million input tokens and $50 per million output tokens, with cached input at $1.00 per million, a 90% discount (OpenAI). Context is 1M tokens and the knowledge cutoff is April 30, 2026 (Artificial Analysis). Its Intelligence Index is 53, tied with Claude Fable 5.1 and 6 points over GPT-5.6 Sol.

The headline number is cost: $3.26 per Intelligence Index task at max and $0.82 at low, the cheapest of the three. Output is about 27K tokens per task at max, roughly a third of Fable 5.1 and about a quarter of Opus 5.5. In Codex it scores 62 on the Coding Agent Index, tying Fable 5.1 at 62 and ahead of Claude Opus 5 at 60; cost per coding task is $7.09, about 40% cheaper than Fable 5.1. Hallucination rate fell from 92% on GPT-5.6 Sol to 51%, while accuracy rose 4 points (Artificial Analysis). Speed is 60.9 output tokens per second against a median of 79, and time to first token p95 is 332 seconds, which is very high.

The caveat: GDPval-AA v2 is about 45 Elo below GPT-5.6 Sol, and it uses 24 turns per task instead of 45 — shorter work sessions (Artificial Analysis). If you are comparing the previous OpenAI generation, our GPT-5.6 review covers that model.

Grok 4.7: fast and cheap per token

Grok 4.7 is the fastest and cheapest per token: $2 input and $6 output per million tokens, roughly 188 output tokens per second on long prompts, and about 7.1 minutes per task. It has a 500K-token context window, the smallest here, and scores 46 on the Intelligence Index with 47% accuracy.

xAI released Grok 4.7 on 2026-09-21. At $2 per million input tokens and $6 per million output tokens, it has the lowest per-token price of the three; cache hits cost $0.50 per million, and a fast variant runs at 2x output speed for 2x price (xAI). Context is 500K tokens with a June 2026 cutoff (Artificial Analysis). On the Intelligence Index it scores 46, up 2 from Grok 4.6 but 7 below GPT-6 Astra and 12 below Opus 5.5.

Speed is the story: about 188 output tokens per second on long prompts and about 7.1 minutes per task, the fastest of the three. On the Coding Agent Index it scores 56 with Grok Build, up 9 from Grok 4.6, ranking fourth behind Fable 5.1, GPT-6 Astra, and Opus 5.5. Components: DeepSWE 73%, Terminal-Bench 4.0 33%, and SWE-Atlas-QnA 63%. Hallucination rate is 29%, down from 34% for Grok 4.6, and accuracy is 47% (Artificial Analysis). It uses about 81K output tokens per task at xhigh, about 3x GPT-6 Astra’s 27K. The limit is clear: smallest context, lowest independent score, and lowest accuracy. For more small-model context, see our Gemini 3 Flash review.

Head-to-head: the honest scoreboard

There is no single winner. Each model leads a different category: Opus 5.5 on independent Intelligence Index at 58, GPT-6 Astra on measured cost per finished task at $3.26 and coding agent work at 62 in Codex, and Grok 4.7 on per-token price at $2/$6 and speed. The table below puts the trade-offs side by side.

CategoryClaude Opus 5.5GPT-6 AstraGrok 4.7
Price / free tier$4/1M input, $20/1M output, cache read $0.20/1M; No verified free tier in sources$10/1M input, $50/1M output, cached input $1.00/1M; No verified free tier in sources$2/1M input, $6/1M output, cache hits $0.50/1M; No verified free tier in sources
Key features1M context; 128K max output; June 2026 cutoff; adaptive thinking always on; fast mode up to 2.5x speed (Anthropic)1M context; April 30, 2026 cutoff; Codex integration; max output not stated in sources (Artificial Analysis)500K context; June 2026 cutoff; fast variant at 2x output speed for 2x price; Grok Build and Cursor access (xAI)
StrengthsHighest independent Intelligence Index at 58 (Artificial Analysis)Lowest measured per-task cost, $3.26 at max and $0.82 at low; Coding Agent Index 62 in CodexLowest per-token price at $2/$6; fastest at ~188 tokens/sec
Limits~119K output tokens per task at max; higher cost per hard runGDPval-AA v2 ~45 Elo below GPT-5.6 Sol; 24 turns/task instead of 45500K context, Intelligence Index 46, 47% accuracy
Best-fit use caseHard knowledge work where reasoning depth matters more than per-task costHigh-volume automated agent work where per-finished-task cost dominatesFast, cheap, light work where latency and token price matter most
Intelligence Index (independent)585346
Output tokens per task (max)~119K~27K~81K

FAQ: quick beginner answers

The fastest way to choose is to match the model to your bottleneck. If you need the hardest answers, pay for Opus 5.5. If you run high-volume automated agents, GPT-6 Astra’s measured per-task cost is the deciding number. If you need fast, light, cheap responses, Grok 4.7 fits. Below are four common beginner questions answered plainly.

Which model is actually cheapest?

GPT-6 Astra is the cheapest measured per Intelligence Index task at $3.26 at max settings, despite its higher per-token price.

Should I pay for the highest Intelligence Index score?

No — only if hard knowledge work is your bottleneck; otherwise per-task cost, speed and use case matter more.

Is Grok 4.7 the most reliable because its hallucination rate is lower?

No — its 29% hallucination rate comes with the lowest accuracy of the three at 47%.

Can I turn off Claude Opus 5.5’s thinking to save money?

No — adaptive thinking is always on and cannot be disabled per Anthropic’s documentation.

How to choose in 60 seconds

A three-buyer rule of thumb: hard knowledge work points to Claude Opus 5.5; high-volume automated agent work points to GPT-6 Astra; fast, cheap, light work points to Grok 4.7. No model wins every category, so your bottleneck — reasoning depth, volume cost, or latency — should decide the pick.

If your bottleneck is reasoning depth, you want the model that scores highest on independent evaluation, and that is Opus 5.5 at 58 (Artificial Analysis). If your bottleneck is volume cost, you want the lowest measured cost per finished task, and that is GPT-6 Astra at $3.26 at max and $0.82 at low (Artificial Analysis). If your bottleneck is latency and light spend, you want the fastest and cheapest per token, and that is Grok 4.7 at about 188 tokens/sec (Artificial Analysis).

Two extra moves help beginners avoid overpaying. First, batch or cache where the vendor supports it: Opus 5.5 cache reads are $0.20 per million tokens and the Batch API is 50% off (Anthropic platform), while GPT-6 Astra cached input is $1.00 per million (OpenAI). Second, if your work is small enough, check whether a cheaper model gets the job done before paying for a frontier model — our DeepSeek V4 Flash review and our run-AI-on-your-laptop guide cover lower-cost options.

Verdict: which should you pick?

Pick Claude Opus 5.5 for hard knowledge work, GPT-6 Astra for high-volume automated agent work, and Grok 4.7 for fast, cheap, light work. Each pick comes with a trade-off: Opus costs more per hard run, Astra regressed on GDPval-AA v2, and Grok has the smallest context and lowest accuracy. There is no overall winner.

Pick Claude Opus 5.5 for hard knowledge work. Reason: it has the highest independent Intelligence Index score at 58, a 1M-token context window, 128K max output, and always-on thinking (Artificial Analysis). Trade-off: about 119K output tokens per task and more cost per hard run. It is not the cheapest option, and you should not treat it as one.

Pick GPT-6 Astra for high-volume automated agent work. Reason: it has the lowest measured per-task cost at $3.26 at max and $0.82 at low, about 27K tokens per task, and a Coding Agent Index of 62 in Codex (Artificial Analysis). Trade-off: the GDPval-AA v2 regression of about 45 Elo below GPT-5.6 Sol and shorter 24-turn sessions (Artificial Analysis). It does not win every benchmark.

Pick Grok 4.7 for fast, cheap, light work. Reason: $2/$6 pricing, about 188 tokens per second, about 7.1 minutes per task, and day-one Cursor/Grok Build access (xAI). Trade-off: 500K context, Intelligence Index 46, and 47% accuracy (Artificial Analysis). It is not the most reliable or the sharpest, and it is not meant to be.

The honest answer is that your workload picks the model, not the leaderboard. If you are still unsure which category you fall into, start with the AI model comparison hub and match the task, not the marketing.

Back to all posts